×

Higher Rates Could Hurt More Than Help: Why the Fed’s Plan Is Under Fire

Higher Rates Could Hurt More Than Help: Why the Fed’s Plan Is Under Fire

The Federal Reserve’s plans for further interest-rate increases are drawing criticism from analysts who believe policymakers could be misreading the latest inflation trends. Recent declines in gasoline, crude oil and a wide range of commodities suggest that price pressures may already be cooling, raising questions about whether additional monetary tightening is necessary.

Market observers argue that the central bank is relying too heavily on outdated economic reports, particularly the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Producer Price Index (PPI). Since these indicators reflect price changes from the previous month, they may fail to capture the speed at which current market conditions are changing.

Forward-looking measures, including gasoline futures, refining margins and prices at fuel stations, are instead pointing toward easing inflation.

“Inflation is a lagging indicator. It tells you what you paid last month. The crack spread is a leading indicator. It tells you what you’ll pay next month. One says inflation is too high. The other says it’s already falling. The Fed is listening to the first one. It’s about to hike into falling prices at the pump,” said Thierry Borgeat, co-founder and chief investment officer of Zurich-based asset manager Arvy, which is regulated by Swiss financial watchdog FINMA.

The possibility of further rate increases is also becoming a concern for Bitcoin investors. Higher borrowing costs typically discourage investment in volatile assets and can create unfavorable conditions for cryptocurrency markets.

Recent comments from Federal Reserve policymakers, alongside the minutes of the October meeting, have reinforced expectations of additional monetary tightening.

The minutes published Wednesday showed that nearly all participants considered further increases in the federal funds rate potentially appropriate over the coming months. Officials cited their expectations for inflation and employment, maintaining that additional action could help return inflation to the central bank’s 2% objective.

Two policymakers suggested that the Fed might need to increase rates by more than 25 basis points in December if upcoming inflation data proved unfavorable. One basis point equals 0.01 percentage point, making 25 basis points equivalent to a quarter-percentage-point increase.

Fed Governor Christopher Waller also supported a more aggressive approach, telling CNBC on Wednesday that he favored a 50-basis-point increase in December. This would be twice the size of the Fed’s conventional quarter-point adjustment.

Governor Michael Barr indicated that higher rates could also be necessary, while San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly called for a gradual approach.

Additional tightening could increase borrowing expenses, restrict financial liquidity and reduce investor demand for risk-sensitive assets such as Bitcoin.

However, critics argue that policymakers are placing too much emphasis on October’s inflation reports. Although CPI and PPI data showed price increases across a broader range of goods and services, they do not reflect the latest decline in energy costs and commodity prices.

Energy has remained a major contributor to inflation since the Iran war began in early March.

Crack spread points to declining fuel costs

Recent movements in the refining industry are providing evidence that inflationary pressure could be weakening faster than the Fed anticipates.

The crack spread measures the difference between the cost of crude oil and the selling price of refined products, including gasoline and diesel. It essentially represents the profit refiners earn from processing crude into usable fuels.

A widely monitored benchmark is the 3-2-1 crack spread, which assumes that refiners produce two barrels of gasoline and one barrel of diesel from three barrels of crude oil.

When this spread contracts, it generally indicates that refined fuel prices are falling faster than crude prices. Such a development can eventually lead to cheaper gasoline for consumers.

According to data shared by James E. Thorne, chief market strategist at wealth management firm Wellington Altus, the 3-2-1 crack spread has fallen 36% in six weeks.

The indicator declined from $65.56 per barrel to $41.90 as of Wednesday, reflecting a sharp reduction in refining margins.

Thorne believes the decline highlights growing pressure across fuel markets. Strong refining profits previously encouraged producers to increase output, but higher production has now contributed to an oversupply of gasoline and diesel.

He also cited a roughly 20% decline in wholesale RBOB gasoline futures and retail fuel prices near $3.78 per gallon as evidence of weakening fuel costs.

RBOB futures track wholesale gasoline prices traded on the NYMEX. They dropped 11.1% and 6.1% during the previous two completed weeks, producing a combined decline of approximately 16.5%.

The contracts have lost another 4.4% so far this week, bringing their three-week decline close to 20%. CoinDesk’s analysis of TradingView data shows that this is the sharpest drop since March 2020.

Retail gasoline prices are following the same direction. AAA data showed that the average U.S. price of regular gasoline reached $3.75 per gallon on Thursday.

The figure is 12.8% lower than a month ago and down 4.9% over the previous week. Despite the recent correction, prices remain approximately 22% above their level from a year earlier.

Thorne expects additional declines because changes in wholesale fuel markets typically take several weeks to reach retail prices.

He estimated that a 10-cent reduction in gasoline prices could lower headline CPI by approximately nine basis points. Based on current market conditions, he believes November could produce a negative headline inflation reading. By March, the previous war-related increase in energy prices would also disappear from year-over-year comparisons.

Thorne argued that the latest developments reflect excess fuel supply rather than deteriorating consumer demand. In his view, declining energy costs are already helping the Fed control inflation, reducing the justification for further interest-rate increases.

Commodity funds reveal broader price weakness

The downward movement in gasoline and crude oil has spread across other commodity markets, suggesting that inflationary pressures may be easing beyond the energy sector.

Ryan Detrick, chief market strategist at Carson Investment Research, tracked the performance of commodity exchange-traded funds through Wednesday’s market close. These investment products generally hold futures contracts, meaning their performance may not precisely match movements in underlying spot prices.

The gasoline ETF (UGA) has declined 20.9% month to date. Meanwhile, the United States crude oil fund (USO) has fallen 19.4%, and the Brent crude ETF (BNO) has lost 18.7%.

Other commodity-linked investments have also recorded substantial declines. Broad commodity funds are down approximately 12%, while the copper ETF (CPER) has dropped 12.5%.

Agricultural commodities have weakened as well, with wheat ETF (WEAT) losing 4.6% and corn ETF (CORN) declining 2.7%. Gold ETF (GLD) has also fallen 4.1% during the same period.

Natural gas has moved against the broader trend, gaining 16.9% this month.

The widespread decline has prompted some market participants to question the Fed’s continued hawkish stance, particularly as energy prices and other commodity costs move lower.

James Lavish, co-managing partner of Bitcoin Opportunity Fund, questioned the reasoning behind calls for a potential 50-basis-point increase in December despite growing evidence of easing energy inflation.

He suggested that the Fed’s aggressive public messaging could be an attempt to pressure financial markets before policymakers eventually decide to halt further rate increases.

Meanwhile, interest-rate futures are reflecting expectations of a 25-basis-point increase in December, another quarter-point move in January and a potential additional increase by April.

Share this content:

Copyright © 2025 CoinsNewz