For years, the crypto industry has debated the integrity of Tether’s reserves—often loudly, and often without much nuance. But the latest round of scrutiny is more sophisticated, grounded, and consequential than past cycles of speculation.
Tether has once again become the focal point for traders, who are revisiting a persistent question: Is the world’s most systemically important stablecoin as sturdy as its reported reserves imply?
The controversy itself is familiar. In earlier years, critics on the fringes—dubbed “Tether truthers”—frequently accused the company of artificially inflating crypto markets and warned that bitcoin would collapse once Tether unraveled. These theories rarely held up under scrutiny.
This time, however, the debate is being led by credible market participants, signaling a deeper divide over how to measure Tether’s financial resilience.
BitMEX co-founder Arthur Hayes argues that Tether’s growing allocation to bitcoin and gold may weaken its buffer against market downturns, as declines in those assets could reduce the company’s stated equity cushion.
But Joseph Ayoub, former Citi crypto research lead, argues that this interpretation is incomplete. Tether’s reserve breakdown, he notes, does not reflect the entirety of its corporate balance sheet, which includes equity stakes, mining operations, diversified corporate assets, and one of the most profitable Treasury investment portfolios globally. Taken as a whole, Ayoub says, Tether appears to have substantial loss-absorbing capacity.
Where concerns become more concrete is around liquidity, not solvency.
Tether keeps limited cash on hand and operates through a constrained set of banking partners, raising questions about how quickly the company could convert its largely non-cash holdings in a sudden redemption surge.
Most of USDT’s backing sits in short-term Treasuries, reverse repos, money market funds, gold, and bitcoin—high-quality assets, but not all equally liquid, especially if multiple markets are under pressure simultaneously.
In normal market conditions, this structure works well. Redemptions tend to be limited because most users recirculate USDT within crypto platforms rather than redeeming it for fiat.
The unresolved question is what happens if that behavior changes. A regulatory shock in offshore hubs or a major disruption in Asia’s trading centers could trigger a wave of redemptions that tests Tether’s ability to unwind positions and move dollars quickly through its banking rails.
A significant real-world stress test occurred in 2022, when Tether processed more than $2 billion in redemptions in a single day, all honored at par for verified clients. Tether cites this as proof that its assets can be mobilized rapidly even during periods of intense volatility. Still, that episode does not fully address how the system would hold up during a longer or disorderly redemption cycle.
Tether maintains that critics misunderstand its broader financial position and continues to dismiss negative interpretations as lacking context.
What makes the current debate meaningful is its tone: measured, professional, and rooted in real market experience. The conversation is being shaped by the traders, builders, and analysts who rely on USDT every day and who are evaluating its liquidity mechanics and reserve composition with clear eyes.
There is no talk of hidden conspiracies or imminent failure—only a serious, pragmatic discussion about balance sheets, redemption dynamics, and market infrastructure. And as USDT becomes increasingly integral to Asia’s trading flows, this level of scrutiny may be both overdue and necessary.
Market Movement
BTC:
Bitcoin trades near $86,436, after briefly dipping toward $84,000 amid hawkish Bank of Japan commentary that pressured global risk assets.
ETH:
Ether holds around $2,794, extending its decline as treasury-linked ETH trades fell more than 10% during Monday’s crypto–equity pullback.
Gold:
Gold opened at $4,218.50, approached $4,300, and strengthened as investors reduced exposure to risk assets and priced in an 87.6% chance of a Fed rate cut next week.
Nikkei 225:
Japan’s Nikkei 225 gained 0.54%, led by financials, energy, and materials, while industrial leaders like Fanuc and NGK Insulators advanced despite JGB yields reaching multi-decade highs.
Share this content:
